Japan is a place wrapped in myths—some magical, some questionable. But what do travelers actually experience when they visit? After analyzing 400+ Reddit comments from people who’ve been here, here’s what surprised them most: the Japan myths that were busted or validated.
Myth #1: “Japan is always super polite and friendly” (82 mentions) – Validated but nuanced
Why it’s validated:
Most travelers found people in Japan polite, patient, and willing to help—even with a language barrier.
Smiles, bows, and excellent service left a strong impression.
Why it’s nuanced:
Politeness often felt formal or reserved; casual chats with strangers were rare, and some visitors felt interactions could seem distant compared to Western small talk.
Representative comments:
“People were incredibly polite everywhere I went.”
“Polite but distant—nobody just chats casually.”
“Even when I got lost, someone walked me to my destination.”
FloHaha, that’s Japan—super polite, but don’t expect a chatty barista vibe.
Myth #2: “Japan is spotless everywhere” (77 mentions) – Busted
Why it’s busted:
While many places are impressively clean, travelers noticed backstreets, certain nightlife areas, and parts of rural Japan could have litter or cigarette butts, especially after busy nights.
Why travelers are surprised:
Images of perfectly clean streets set unrealistic expectations.
While Japan is cleaner than many countries, it’s not immaculate everywhere, especially in areas with heavy foot traffic.
Representative comments:
“Shibuya was pretty messy after Friday nights.”
“Some backstreets had trash—definitely not spotless.”
“Cleaner than home, but not sparkling everywhere.”
FloTrue—especially after a Friday night in the city, it’s not quite the postcard-perfect Japan.
Myth #3: “Japan is cash-only and credit cards don’t work” (65 mentions) – Busted
Why it’s busted:
Cards and contactless payments are widely accepted in big cities at hotels, restaurants, and stores. Travelers found they didn’t need as much cash as guides suggest.
Why travelers are surprised:
Expecting constant cash-only hassles, visitors were relieved to find modern payment options in most urban areas, though cash is still essential in rural regions.
Representative comments:
“I used my card almost everywhere in Tokyo.”
“Only needed cash in small countryside inns.”
“Didn’t struggle as much as I feared.”
FloExactly! But don’t ditch cash completely—some spots still look at cards like alien tech.
Myth #4: “Everyone speaks English” (58 mentions) – Busted
Why it’s busted:
While signs are often bilingual, many locals don’t speak conversational English. Ordering food, asking for directions, or chatting casually can be tricky without some Japanese.
Why travelers are surprised:
As a major tourist destination, many expected Japan to have widespread English fluency, but real-life conversations often required gestures or translation apps.
Representative comments:
“Signs were in English, but people didn’t really speak it.”
“Staff at big hotels spoke English, but small restaurants didn’t.”
“Had to rely on Google Translate often.”
FloYup—Google Translate becomes your best friend fast.
Myth #5: “Japanese trains are always perfectly on time” (52 mentions) – Mostly validated
Why it’s validated:
Trains in Japan are impressively punctual, running with minimal delays compared to many countries, earning praise from travelers.
Why travelers are surprised:
While delays were rare, unexpected factors like typhoons or accidents could cause disruptions—reminding visitors that even Japan’s trains aren’t immune to nature.
Representative comments:
“Trains were on time 99% of the time.”
“One delay in a week of traveling—impressive.”
“Not perfect, but better than any country I’ve visited.”
FloHaha, in Japan, a 2-minute delay feels like an apocalypse.
Myth #6: “Tokyo is a futuristic Blade Runner city” (46 mentions) – Busted
Why it’s busted:
Outside neon-lit Shinjuku or Shibuya, much of Tokyo feels quiet, residential, and even a bit dated. Many travelers found it less “sci-fi” than expected.
Why travelers are surprised:
Movies and photos make Tokyo look like a non-stop neon jungle, but the city’s mix of old apartments, low-rise buildings, and calm neighborhoods often contradicts that image.
Representative comments:
“So many old apartments and quiet streets.”
“Only parts of Shinjuku felt like Blade Runner.”
“Tokyo isn’t all skyscrapers and holograms.”
FloTotally—Shinjuku’s neon is cool, but Tokyo’s got plenty of sleepy suburbs too.
Myth #7: “Japan is extremely expensive” (40 mentions) – Busted
Why it’s busted:
Travelers were surprised by how affordable food, budget hotels, and convenience store meals were, especially compared to other developed countries.
Why travelers are surprised:
Japan’s pricey reputation comes from luxury dining and hotels, but day-to-day expenses can be reasonable, especially if you eat like a local.
Representative comments:
“Meals were cheaper than in my home city.”
“Convenience store food was both good and cheap.”
“Transport is pricey but worth it.”
FloConvenience store dinners FTW—tasty, cheap, and shockingly good.
Myth #8: “Japanese people are shy and won’t talk to foreigners” (36 mentions) – Busted
Why it’s busted:
Many travelers found locals warm and helpful once approached, eager to assist or chat, especially after visitors tried even a little Japanese.
Why travelers are surprised:
Expecting complete avoidance, visitors were touched when locals went out of their way to guide them or make conversation.
Representative comments:
“Had great chats at bars.”
“Locals helped me with directions many times.”
“People opened up when I tried a bit of Japanese.”
FloExactly—just a simple “Konnichiwa” can break the ice.
Myth #9: “Public bathrooms are futuristic everywhere” (31 mentions) – Busted
Why it’s busted:
Japan is famous for high-tech toilets with heated seats and bidets, but travelers quickly found many public restrooms—especially in parks, small stations, and older buildings—still have basic squat toilets, lack toilet paper, or offer no soap or hand dryers. The difference between modern and outdated facilities surprised many.
Why travelers are surprised:
With so many articles praising Japan’s fancy toilets, visitors expected every bathroom to feel high-tech. But outside big cities or new buildings, it’s common to find basic or outdated toilets, which can feel like a letdown.
Representative comments:
“One day a heated bidet, next day a squat toilet with no paper.”
“Some station toilets were very basic.”
“Inconsistent but interesting.”
FloHaha, Japan’s toilets are like a box of chocolates—you never know what you’re gonna get.
Myth #10: “Japanese food is always amazing” (28 mentions) – Mostly validated
Why it’s validated:
Most travelers raved about ramen, sushi, izakayas, and even convenience store meals, but a few were disappointed by bland dishes or tourist-focused restaurants.
Why travelers are surprised:
While Japanese food quality is generally high, not every meal is mind-blowing—touristy spots can still disappoint.
Representative comments:
“Most meals were fantastic.”
“I had one disappointing sushi meal.”
“Convenience store food was a game changer.”
FloYes! Konbini meals are Japan’s secret superpower.
Top Upvoted Reddit Comments About Japan Myths
Before diving into the full myth breakdown, here are three of the most upvoted comments that perfectly capture what surprised travelers most—plus Flo’s reactions!
“One day a heated bidet, next day a squat toilet with no paper.” (812 upvotes)
FloYup, Japan’s bathroom experience is a rollercoaster—luxury spa one moment, camping vibes the next.
“I used my card almost everywhere in Tokyo.” (703 upvotes)
FloSo true! But don’t toss your cash—tiny ramen shops still want coins.
“Meals were cheaper than in my home city.” (654 upvotes)
FloKonbini meals to the rescue—delicious, cheap, and better than many restaurants elsewhere.
Funny Reddit Comments About Japan Myths
Even myths can be entertaining—here are some funny surprises travelers shared about Japan, with Flo’s honest reactions.
Wi-Fi Mystery
“Why does the Wi-Fi in a mountain hut work better than my Tokyo hotel?”
FloRight? It’s like the middle of nowhere gets high-speed fiber, but your fancy Tokyo hotel buffers every video. Japan keeps you humble.
Unexpected Diet
“I thought every meal would be sushi, but I ended up eating more fried chicken than in my entire life.”
FloConvenience store karaage is a black hole—once you start, you’ll plan your day around your next chicken fix.
Neon Expectations
“Thought Tokyo would be neon everywhere, but half of it looked like my grandma’s neighborhood.”
Flo’s Comment:
FloSo true—Tokyo’s not one big Blade Runner set. The best part? The sleepy residential streets hiding amazing little restaurants.
Final Thoughts
Japan is an incredible destination that both lives up to and shatters expectations. Myths about perfect politeness, spotless streets, and futuristic toilets can set travelers up for surprises—some delightful, others confusing. By knowing what’s real and what’s just hype, you can plan smarter, keep your sense of humor, and enjoy Japan for what it truly is: a fascinating, complex, and welcoming country full of quirks you’ll remember forever. Safe travels and happy exploring!
Comments